I especially liked your characterization of the current debate as a kashya on secularism. The four questions the youngest participant at the Passover Seder asks are also considered to be kashyas. Perhaps if we were all of us wise we would see these as koans, not meant to be answered individually from our own perspectives on each question, but as forming a multidimensional möbius strip we are meant to traverse.
I especially liked your characterization of the current debate as a kashya on secularism. The four questions the youngest participant at the Passover Seder asks are also considered to be kashyas. Perhaps if we were all of us wise we would see these as koans, not meant to be answered individually from our own perspectives on each question, but as forming a multidimensional möbius strip we are meant to traverse.
I think you mean indigeneity rather than indigineity ( see https://johansandbergmcguinne.wordpress.com/official-definitions-of-indigeneity/ )